Saradha Chit Fund: ED questions ex-TMC MP Kunal Ghosh

The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Wednesday questioned former Trinamool Congress MP Kunal Ghosh in its probe into the Saradha Chit Fund scam.

A senior ED official told IANS: “Ghosh is being questioned for his role in the Saradha Chit Fund case under sections of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act.”

The official said that the agency is questioning Ghosh about the financial transactions of the Saradha group.

On being asked when the agency has summoned Trinamool Congress sitting MP Satabdi Roy, East Bengal football club official Debabrata Sarkar, businessmen Sajjan Agarwal, Sandhir Agarwal and Saradha Group Chairman Sudipta Sen’s close aide Arindam Das, he said, “They have been asked to appear in August before ED.”

The Saradha scam came to light in April 2013 and is estimated at over Rs 10,000 crore. The ED has filed a case on the basis of the CBI’s FIR.



Saradha Scam; Singhvi says CBI playing a political game

Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi appearing for former Kolkata Commissioner of Police (CP) Rajeev Kumar in the Saradha scam case submitted before the Supreme Court on Wednesday that the whole episode of the CBI insisting on Kumar’s arrest is a political game to keep the pot boiling and paint people black.

During the second consecutive hearing in the case, a bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Ranjan Gogoi asked the CBI to produce the case diary. After observing the papers, the court said the case diary is in the form of loose sheets of paper which are vulnerable to tampering, and, instead, should be properly bound as mandatorily required.

“Should not CBI follow the mandate of the law with regards to the case diary… fact case diary should have been uploaded ” the court said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta appearing for the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) said there is prima facie evidence regarding the destruction of evidence in the scam and, therefore, custodial interrogation of Kumar is required.

The court observed: “Many countries in the world do not allow custodial interrogation..”

Kumar had earlier filed an affidavit directly accusing the CBI of acting at the behest of two BJP leaders – Mukul Roy and Kailash Vijayavargiya – while targeting him in the Sharadha and Rose Valley scams.

Singhvi contended before the court that the CBI had never filed an FIR regarding the destruction of evidence in the scam, but the agency was now demanding Kumar’s arrest. The investigation in the scam was handed over to the CBI in May 2014.

Singhvi told the court that five years after the handing over of the case, the CBI is suddenly seeking Kumar’s arrest.
He said that all the electronic evidence in the case had been handed over.

“Kumar had thrice appeared before the CBI regarding the investigations into the scam….but the demand for his arrest was propped up after the incident, in February, ” he added.

The court pointed out that the investigating officer in the case has recorded a statement under Section 161 before a Magistrate, and sought a response on it from Kumar’s counsel .

Singhvi said that they had already filed an affidavit, but the court demanded a response on the statement recorded before a judge.

Senior advocate Indira Jaisingh intervened and sought the court’s attention, to which the CJI asked her as to who she represented. Jaisingh said she is representing Kumar in his personal capacity, while Singhvi is representing the former Commissioner of Police.

The apex court will continue to hear the matter on Thursday.



Saradha and Rose Valley multi-crore ponzi scams; The lowdown

The latest stand-off between the Narendra Modi-led central government and West Bengals Mamata Banerjee government has again brought the two multi-crore ponzi scams – Saradha and Rose Valley – into the mainstream of the political discourse.

With the Lok Sabha polls barely months away, the twin scandals look likely to emerge as key issues not only in West Bengal, but also in neighbouring states like Odisha and Assam.

Here’s a dossier on the the two scams and the investigations into them:

The Saradha scam

Founded in 2006, the Saradha Group chief, Sudipta Sen’s chit fund, through various collective investment schemes, mopped up Rs 3,500 crore from 17 lakh investors in investors in West Bengal, Assam, Jharkhand, Tripura and Odisha before it collapsed in April 2013.

The group, which had close links with politicians, had built up its brand by investing in media and CSR (corporate social responsibility) projects.

The Income Tax and Enforcement Directorate initiated probes against the scam and other ponzi schemes.

In 2013, after the scam came to light, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee formed a Special Investigation Team led by Rajeev Kumar, now the Calcutta Police Commissioner and in the eye of the storm over the latest confrontation between the central and state governments.

The Supreme Court had transferred the investigation into the Saradha and other ponzi schemes to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in 2014 citing inter-state implications and possible international money laundering.

The CBI found irregularities of about Rs 2,500 crore and properties worth around Rs 1,000 crore have been attached across various states.

Sudipta Sen, considered the kingpin of the scam, had fled soon after depositors hit the streets demanding justice. Sen, arrested from Gulmarg in Jammu & Kashmir, is currently in judicial custody.

Debjani Mukherjee, a director of the Saradha group, had fled with Sen after the scam was unearthed. Mukherjee was also arrested from Gulmarg. Her salary was reportedly Rs 1 lakh per month by cheque and another Rs 1 lakh in cash, apart from other perks and privileges. The SIT has filed a charge-sheet against her.

Kunal Ghosh was CEO of Saradha Group’s media arm. He was arrested by Bidhannagar Police under sections 420 (cheating), 406 (criminal breach of trust) and 120B (conspiracy) of the IPC. Ghosh, a journalist-turned politician, was suspended by the Trinamool Congress.

After the CBI took over the case on the Supreme Court’s order to probe the larger conspiracy, the agency filed a charge-sheet naming Sen, Mukherjee and Ghosh. He was granted interim bail in October, 2016.

Rajat Majumdar: Former West Bengal DGP (Armed Police) Majumdar’s name cropped up in the scam and the CBI arrested him in September 2014. He was, in February 2015, granted conditional bail by the Calcutta High Court.

Srinjoy Bose: Former Trinamool Congress Rajya Sabha member and former editor of party mouthpiece Jago Bangla was arrested in November, 2014 by the CBI. Bose had been involved with the management of iconic football club Mohun Bagan in which the group reportedly had invested along with another soccer giant, East Bengal. Bose was granted bail in January, 2018.

Madan Mitra: Trinamool Congress leader and former West Bengal Minister, Mitra was arrested by the central agency in December, 2014. He was seen in videos clips praising Saradha Group chief Sudipta Sen at a meeting. Mitra, known to be one of Mamata Banerjee’s most trusted aides and a founder-member of the Trinamool, also allegedly enjoyed benefits from the group. He was granted bail in September, 2016.

Debabrata Sarkar: The CBI arrested East Bengal Club official Debabrata Sarkar, alias Nitu, after sleuths found a “few incriminating documents”.

Sadananda Gogoi: Assamese singer Sadananda Gogoi was arrested by the federal agency for allegedly taking money from Saradha Realty and helping the fraudulent company operate freely in Assam.

Rose Valley

The Rose Valley ponzi scheme scam run by the Group’s Chairman, Gautam Kundu, was unearthed in 2013. The group allegedly floated 27 companies to run various schemes. It allegedly collected Rs 17,520 crore from depositors in West Bengal, Assam and Bihar. The Enforcement Directorate, which investigated the scam along with the CBI, has attached assets including resorts, hotels, and land worth Rs 2,300 crore and recovered incriminating documents, gold ornaments and precious stones worth Rs 40 crore during searches at showrooms of a jewellery house in connection with the scam.

Gautam Kundu: The CBI arrested Kundu under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and registered an FIR against him and the company in 2014. He was arrested in 2015 and has since been in jail.

Sudip Bandyopadhyay: Trinamool Congress leader in the Lok Saha Sudip Bandyopadhyay was arrested by CBI for allegedly helping the group extend its network. The agency filed a charge-sheet under sections 120-B (criminal conspiracy), 409 (criminal breach of trust) and 5420 (cheating) of the IPC. He was granted bail in May 2017 by the Orissa High Court.

Tapas Pal: Actor and Trinamool Congress MP Tapas Pal was arrested by CBI for allegedly helping the Rose Valley group run ponzi schemes. According to the agency, he was paid by the group for lending support to its illegitimate business. He got bail in February 2018.